The character of the clouds with in the play the clouds, play an interesting role in the understanding of the just versus unjust argument aristophanes’ traditional views are brought out by the chorus of clouds in true satire nature in the form of engulfing a dual characterization directly addressing the audience. This 5 page paper compares two ancient greek texts, the unjust speech in aristophanes' play the clouds and the athenian thesis in thucydides, and examines the ways in which each text discusses the issues of what is just and unjust, as well as what defines weakness and strength. Just vs unjust speech: comparing the clouds and the republic anonymous college socrates, a famous ancient greek philosopher, is depicted as ridiculous in the clouds by aristophanes yet as thoughtful in the republic by plato. Throughout aristophanes’ “clouds” there is a constant battle between old and new it makes itself apparent in the just and unjust speech as well as between father and son ultimately, pheidippides, whom would be considered ‘new’, triumphs over the old strepsiades, his father this is .
Aristophanes, clouds they teach, upon some payment, how to win, whether one’s just or unjust oppose in speech each speech he is “eager” to see the . Just speech means that in the past unjust speech lived beggar-like off meager scraps of food in a pouch, and that the scraps were legalistic and sophistic quibbles. The clouds strepsiades (sitting up in his bed) i have a desire just now to ease myself socrates literature network » aristophanes » the clouds » the . The argument of just and unjust in the clouds, a comedy by aristophanes culminates with unjust apparently winning the day in book 1 of the republic.
“the clouds” (gr: “nephelai”) is a comedy by the ancient greek playwright aristophanes, originally produced at the athens city dionysia of 423 bce it is perhaps the world's first extant “comedy of ideas” and lampoons intellectual fashions in classical athens. Just speech blames unjust speech for the current corruption of the city’s youth, who no longer have respect for their parents, the gods, or the city and its laws moderation and restraint are the behaviors to practice, says just speech. A summary of act one: parabasis of scene 2–scene 3 in aristophanes's the clouds learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of the clouds and what it means.
Just and unjust speech in aristophanes' clouds essay 599 words | 3 pages throughout aristophanes’ “clouds” there is a constant battle between old and new. It all comes back to education in the clouds the question of how best to prepare people mentally for the challenges of life is a huge question (like, just in general), and aristophanes is definite. Just and unjust speeches are two aspects derived from aristophanes’ play ‘the clouds’ and plato’s in ‘the republic’ according to the aristophanes the speech not only offers some philosophical wits to the educators and the audience, but it offers a resourceful knowledge to the people. The clouds by aristophanes more and more volubly from here to the end of speech a moment later the just and the unjust discourse come out . Within his ancient play ‘the clouds,’ aristophanes examines two particular kinds of speech, just and unjust speech, and their timeless conflict.
Aristophanes’ play, “clouds”, there is a battle between the “old” and “new” way of going out about life this can be seen through the “just” and “unjust” speech, whose argumentative outcomes dictate the way in which society should go about educating its citizens. The just speech doesn’t know rhetoric because he begins by insulting his audience, whereas the unjust speech begins by flattering them which is a clear sign of superior rhetorical skill now, another thing is this: the just speech doesn’t know how to defend what you could call natural inequality and natural authority. Clouds by aristophanes clouds to unjust & just leading cloud to just speech but you who crowned the elders with many upright habits, utter forth your voice .
Get an answer for 'what are the main arguments advanced by the unjust logos in aristophanes' clouds' and find homework help for other the clouds questions at enotes. The platonic and xenophontic socrates, the one that would never teach an unjust speech or hold “clouds” to be responsible for all phenomena, keeps the critique very radical that much aristophanes got right what he missed is why it is essential to not give up on lines of questioning. Just and unjust speech in aristophanes' clouds - throughout aristophanes’ “clouds” there is a constant battle between old and new it makes itself apparent in the just and unjust speech as well as between father and son. What we’re going to find as we look at the contest between the just speech and the unjust speech is that the just speech loses yet the just speech is supposedly the speech that aristophanes is most in synch with.